Geneva expats worry about housing and crime

by Simon Bradley in Geneva, swissinfo.ch
Local crime remains a major concern for expatriates in Geneva, behind finding a flat and ahead of transport hassles, a new poll has revealed.

The Geneva police says expats’ perception of the worsening crime situation “matches the reality on the ground”. But recent police operations in the centre of town seem to be making a difference and preventive and reorganisation measures should help.

According to the survey carried out at the end of 2009 by canton Geneva and Geneva police, in collaboration with the Permanent Mission of Switzerland to the United Nations, 51.8 per cent of expats say housing is their main concern, ahead of insecurity (17 per cent) and transport (14.3 per cent).

The survey presented on Monday found that around 33 per cent of the 1,082 people questioned at diplomatic missions, international organisations and multinationals in Geneva felt there had been a “substantial deterioration” in security in recent years, while 45 per cent said it had “worsened slightly”. Most had lived in Geneva for more than two years and were from a range of different countries.

Yet Geneva remains an excellent place to live and work, the poll added, with around 92 per cent of people saying they would recommend Geneva to their family and friends and 77.3 per cent saying the quality of life was good. Only 18.7 per cent said it was “average” and four per cent “bad”.

“Geneva is relatively safe,” said Victor, an American who has lived and worked in Geneva for the past six years after stints in New York, Tokyo, London and Nairobi. “But there are notorious spots like the Paquis district [between the main station and Lake Geneva] and the Cornavin train station.”

The security situation has worsened noticeably over the past five years and you have to pay more attention to your security and surroundings, he admitted.

But Jovana Carapic, a Canadian research assistant at the Geneva-based Graduate Institute, was surprised by the poll results.

“I’ve lived here for two years and never had a single problem,” she said. “As a young woman I don’t feel unsafe anywhere. I’ve walked in the city in the middle of the night and the day and I felt the same.”

“Frankly worrying”

For Didier Froidevaux, who led the survey on behalf of the Geneva police, the expat results and concerns are similar to those of Geneva locals from a 2007 survey and match the reality on the ground.

“The crime figures have not improved recently. They were stable for two years but last year they went back up due to burglaries,” he told swissinfo.ch.

In March 2010 the new Geneva councillor in charge of the police, Isabel Rochat, described the security situation in Geneva as “frankly worrying”.

Geneva has the highest crime rates in the country, mainly due to burglaries, petty crime, drug dealing and other incivilities.

Some 12.4 per cent of expats reported having been burgled during the past three years and 11.6 per cent said they had been robbed in the street.

Precious asset

Olivier Coutau, a delegate in charge of International Geneva relations, said crime and insecurity in Geneva came up from time to time in talks with foreign diplomats and other expats.

“But the fact we’ve done this poll means that we think it’s an important subject,” he noted. “International Geneva is a precious asset and we have good security that has existed for a long time; we need to preserve it.”

“What is important is what the police do with this poll,” he added.

Police, politicians and local residents have been trying to get to grips with persistent insecurity in the centre of town – especially in the popular lakeside districts of Paquis, Eaux-Vives, Rive and the station – for a number of years.

“Operation Figaro”

But it appears that “Operation Figaro”, launched in April to reduce petty crime in the city centre comprising additional police patrols, is starting to bear fruit.

Thieves and dealers may still be busy in the middle of the night when there are fewer police around, but the level of theft is down by five per cent in the centre and 12 per cent in outer-lying districts compared with 2009, the police claim.

Alain Bittar, owner of the Arab bookshop L'Olivier in the Rue de Fribourg, agreed that proximity policing seemed to have had an impact.

“Something important happened with Figaro,” he said. “From being a lawless zone or jungle, Paquis is now controlled; we have the impression that we were listened to.”

After Figaro, the police intend to keep up the pressure via a greater visible presence on the streets, Froidevaux said.

Next January a new “integrated” police station will be created in the Paquis district bringing together more officers with special skills for tracking thieves and dealers – and more English speaking officers.

And major changes are also planned next month to make investigations into burglaries more efficient, as well as preventive security initiatives with estate agents, housing agencies and owners.

Simon Bradley in Geneva, swissinfo.ch
Rating

Readers' average rating: 4.5


Feedback
Place your feedback

Sarah Eaton, Switzerland

Geneva's dirty little secret is that it is one dangerous city. I'm from New York City and I thought we were moving somewhere safer - not the case at all! We live in centre-ville and have to constantly look over our shoulders - there are petty thieves and thugs EVERYWHERE, and when you point them out to the police, the police just say there's nothing they can do. It's ridiculous. Mothers with prams should especially BEWARE! The real crime situation here is sorely underreported.

alex, Switzerland

The bonneteau games around quai du mont blanc are especially irritating as the guys certainly steal from our mailboxes (i've witnessed this), pick pockets and deal god knows what from the bus station. Schengen is absolutely to blame. Ive had my car busted into twice which never happened in years of street parking in brooklyn and manhattan.

Brona, Ireland

I have lived in Geneva for 15 years and for the first 10 years nothing happened to me in terms of scurity. In the past five years however our house was broken into while we were asleep upstairs, men have tried to get me to leave my car twice so they could snatch my handbag)and I had my purse stolen at Cornavin. For me Geneva is no longer a safe place to live BUT if I was to list the things that happened to me in London or L.A. my list would have been a lot longer. No major city is completely safe. Geneva is getting worse but it has a long way to go.

Daniel, Turkey

It was on a train from Geneva to Bern that I saw, for the first time ever on Swiss soil, someone keeping an eye on the conductor so he could, by moving from one car or one deck to another, ride the train without a ticket. After reading this article, that should never have come as a surprise. Perhaps, just as shown by the current situation of Swedish cities of Malmö and Stockholm, Geneva's inhabitants are just paying the price for being overenthusiastic about multiculturalism in the form of individuals that will always have nothing but utter contempt for Western notions of law and order. You're going to reap just what you sow. That's one more reason why I'd like to see Geneva's smugness and baseless sense of importance and superiority make it secede from the rest of Switzerland. I certainly wouldn't miss having that odd canton among all the others.



Rene, Switzerland

Is it just possible that the United Nations Organization with some of their questionable 'human rights' and asylum policies in addition to the Swiss governments open border (EU) wishes contributed to the crime escalation problem not just in Geneva but generally all over Switzerland?

Rene, Switzerland

Now, who and what regions in Switzerland voted for the Schengen agreements and the open border policy? How about Geneva? Don't cry for me Switzerland now!

Pat, Switzerland

"Some 12.4 per cent of expats reported having been burgled during the past three years and 11.6 per cent said they had been robbed in the street." If that is the truth then this situation is absolutely unacceptable. This is not the Switzerland I knew...but maybe we have to get used to it that in terms of security we are no better than any other EU country anymore. Thank you dear (leftist) politicians.

willy williams, Switzerland

Too many undesirables roaming the streets. They are easily spotted by a trained eye.


(Source: http://www.swissinfo.ch/eng/swiss_news/Geneva_expats_worry_about_housing_and_crime.html?cid=28583534&rss=true )


.


.